This past week was my second visit
to Tunbridge Public Charter School, where I am working with Ms. Stafford and
her 3rd grade class. Tunbridge is different from the other schools I
have visited because it has students from all over the city, and is more diverse
than the typical Baltimore public school. The class I have been placed in has
many excellent, and well-adjusted students; however, there are two students who
have recently become behaviorally concerning, distracting the class, insulting
the teacher, and being overall quite unruly. Both of my visits I have spent
time with these two boys, trying to help them stay on task and work on their
behavior during lessons. My first visit was quite frustrating, as I did not
seem to make any difference in keeping the boys from being trouble during class
time, but my second visit I was greeted by one of the boys, and he was much
more responsive to my efforts this time around. By the end of my two hours
there, he had even been invited to join his peers on the rug during teaching
time, which he had not been permitted to do in a few weeks, and I could see his
excitement when his classmates went so far as to congratulate him on being so
well behaved. Although my first visit was frustrating, and I felt I had not
made any difference, I clearly had an impact on at least one of the students I
worked with, as he went out of his way to behave for me during my next visit.
This week’s readings focused a lot on how minor things may not seem like a big
deal to one person, but from another’s perspective it is endlessly significant.
In
“The Cask of Amontillado”, our narrator opens the story by proclaiming his
hatred for his one-time friend Fortunado, although he does not give us reason
for the sudden change in this relationship. He lures Fortunado into his dungeon-like
basement by telling him he has wine for him to taste. After getting his friend
sufficiently drunk on wine, our narrator lures him into a small nook, chains
him to a stone, and seals the entrance with bricks, where his body has still
not been discovered some 50 years later. Throughout the story, as our narrator
leads Fortunado closer and closer to his death, he remains oblivious to his
impending doom. It is interesting that whatever Fortunado has done was bad
enough to warrant his murder, but was so insignificant to him that even as he
is sealed into his tomb, he cannot fathom any reason why his friend would do
this to him, and interprets his predicament as a joke. Clearly, in this case,
Fortunado has done something that had a great impact on our narrator, without
thinking twice about it.
A
similar message plays out quite differently in “My Papa’s Waltz”. This poem
tells us about a moment the speaker shared with his father that clearly stands
out to him. This moment from when the speaker was a “small boy” sticks with him
so strongly that even so many years later he can still remember the vivid
details of this night. Considering how strongly the smell of whiskey is
described on the father’s breath, he likely does not remember this night too
well, it may not have been particularly significant to him. Like Fortunado’s
slight, the actions of this night resonated with the speaker of the poem, also
in this case in a more positive tone.
This
week’s final reading, “Cincinnati”, is about the speaker moving to a new city,
where they hope to find liberation in the fact that no one there knows them.
This is short lived as they encounter an insult thrown at them in passing,
which manages to cling to them, ruining their feeling of freedom. Again, we
have someone who has made a comment in passing, one that they probably have not
spent too much time thinking about, but radically changed the experience of
another, completely shattering their newfound sense of identity. All three of
these stories show us ways in which things which we do not give a second thought
to can completely overwhelm the life of another, in a positive or negative way.
This is an important thing for us to remember every day in our lives, it is the
reason we need to engage in opportunities like service-learning, and it is the
way we must approach service towards others, such as my interactions with the
children at Tunbridge.
No comments:
Post a Comment